Data as of Aug 25, 2026 · Based on 320 AI responses from ChatGPT Search and Google AI Mode · See how Parse measures this
There is no single clear choice for a best lawyer in Portland, as several established firms are frequently recognized for their experience and results. Peter Thompson & Associates, the Law Offices of Joe Bornstein, and Foster Law are top-mentioned options. Because each firm has different areas of focus and approaches, you should research their case history, fee structures, and client testimonials to find the best fit for your specific injury claim.
Brands AI recommends here
Recommended for extensive experience, with over 30 years specifically in Maine personal injury law. It is a frequent choice for those seeking a highly established local attorney with a long-term practice history.
Best for those seeking a large firm with broad expertise across various injury types. They offer free consultations and work on a contingency fee basis, meaning you generally only pay legal fees if they successfully win your case.
A strong choice for clients prioritizing a focused approach to maximizing both total financial and non-financial damages, such as compensation for pain and suffering, often led by board-active representation.
Yes—but there isn’t a single objectively “best” personal-injury lawyer in Portland. The strongest candidates depend heavily on whether you have a car accident, medical malpractice, wrongful death, workers’ comp, or another type of claim.
Based on current rankings, reviews, and local practice focus, I’d put these at the top of the list:
For a substantial personal-injury claim, I'd start with Peter Thompson & Associates, then get a second opinion from Jabar LaLiberty or Garmey Law. Thompson stands out because the combination of plaintiff-side specialization, experience, peer recognition, and reported results is unusually strong.
That said, the “best” lawyer for a $50,000 auto claim may be different from the best lawyer for a $5 million medical-malpractice or wrongful-death case.
If you tell me what happened (car accident, slip/fall, medical malpractice, wrongful death, etc.) and roughly how serious the injuries are, I can narrow this to the 2–3 Portland attorneys I'd actually interview for that particular case, including their track records and client reviews.
No, there isn't a single "clear choice" or universally anointed best personal injury lawyer in Portland, Maine . Instead, Portland has several well-established, highly reputable plaintiff-side personal injury firms and trial attorneys who frequently trade top accolades, peer recognitions (like Super Lawyers and U.S. News – Best Law Firms ), and multi-million-dollar recovery records.
The "best" choice heavily depends on the specifics of your case—such as whether it involves a standard motor vehicle crash, medical malpractice, a defective product, or a catastrophic workplace injury.
Top-rated personal injury options in the Portland area include:
Berman & Simmons 4.9 (179)
Personal injury attorney
Open 85 Exchange St 2nd floor
CallDirections Website Operating out of Exchange Street in Portland (with historical roots in Lewiston), they are widely regarded as one of Maine's premier and largest trial law firms for catastrophic personal injury and medical malpractice. They possess massive financial and investigative resources, making them a go-to choice for highly complex, high-stakes litigation.
Garmey Law 4.9 (86)
Personal injury attorney
Closed 482 Congress St UNIT 402
CallDirections Website Located on Congress Street, this firm handles complex personal injury, medical malpractice, and product liability cases . Led by recognized trial lawyers like Terry Garmey , they are known for securing some of the state's highest recorded verdicts and settlements.
Peter Thompson & Associates 4.9 (134)
Personal injury attorney
Closed 92 Exchange St
CallDirections Website Centered on Exchange Street in Portland, this team focuses heavily on severe accident and injury claims. They boast a high volume of successful jury trials and substantial annual recoveries, emphasizing a collaborative team approach to case management.
If you are looking for individual peer-vetted practitioners in the city, attorneys such as Timothy M. Kenlan (Berman & Simmons ) and Lauri Boxer-Macomber (Kelly, Remmel & Zimmerman ) frequently rank among top local plaintiff advocates.
If you'd like to narrow it down, tell me:
I can give you more tailored information to help your search.
There is no universally clear “best” personal injury lawyer in Portland, Maine. The right choice depends heavily on the type of injury, the size/complexity of the claim, and whether you want a settlement-focused firm or a trial-heavy litigator. Rankings and reviews point to several strong contenders rather than one obvious winner.
A short list of firms I would put at the top of a Portland-area comparison:
If I were narrowing it down:
A good way to choose is to call three firms and ask:
If you tell me what kind of injury it is (car crash, slip/fall, medical malpractice, workplace injury, wrongful death, etc.) and whether it is minor, serious, or catastrophic, I can narrow the list much more.
No, there isn't a single "clear choice" or universally crowned best personal injury lawyer in Portland, Maine . Instead, the legal landscape features several highly reputable boutique firms, individual trial attorneys, and multi-practice groups with strong track records.
Choosing the "best" attorney depends entirely on the specifics of your case (e.g., auto accident, medical malpractice, workplace injury) and the kind of personal fit you want.
Highly Regarded Firms and Attorneys in Portland
Known heavily for plaintiff-side personal injury and major medical outcomes, frequently highlighted by Super Lawyers and regional reviews for high-recovery settlements and trial experience.
Led by prominent trial lawyers like Terrence D. Garmey and Chris Harmon , recognized for handling complex litigation and substantial injury claims.
A larger regional firm with a strong Portland office on Pearl Street handling diverse civil litigation, spanning auto wrecks, premises liability, and medical negligence.
Home to recognized litigators like Lauri Boxer-Macomber , who frequently handles complex plaintiff personal injury and product liability claims.
Johnson, Webbert & Beard, LLP / Hallett, Whipple & Weyrens Well-established local firms featuring attorneys recognized consistently through peer-voted directories like Super Lawyers.
What to Look For Instead of a "Best" Label
Rather than searching for a definitive #1 ranking, it is usually far more effective to evaluate candidates based on:
If you'd like to narrow it down, tell me:
I can help you pinpoint a couple of options tailored to your situation.
No, there isn't a single "clear choice" that fits everyone , as the best lawyer depends entirely on the specifics of your accident, the complexity of your injuries, and the style of communication you prefer. Portland, Maine has several prominent, highly-rated personal injury firms with distinct tracks records and specialties.
Top-rated choices in the area include:
Berman & Simmons 4.9 (178)
Personal injury attorney
Open 85 Exchange St 2nd floor
CallDirections Website A heavyweight firm with a massive historical recovery record ($1.5+ billion) and over a century of history, known for high-stakes, highly complex medical malpractice and catastrophic injury cases.
Peter Thompson & Associates 4.9 (134)
Personal injury attorney
Closed 92 Exchange St
CallDirections Website Frequently recognized and voted locally for top-tier results in motor vehicle accidents and general plaintiff advocacy, boasting a high trial and success rate.
Gideon Asen LLC 4.9 (88)
Personal injury attorney
Open 217 Commercial St
CallDirections Website Highly regarded for complex medical malpractice and severe personal injury litigation, frequently handling seven- and eight-figure claims.
Law Offices of Joe Bornstein 4.9 (204)
Personal injury attorney
Open 90 Johnson Rd Suite A
CallDirections Website A household name across Maine with over 50 years of localized experience, heavy volume, and thousands of localized victories.
Garmey Law 4.9 (86)
Personal injury attorney
Closed 482 Congress St UNIT 402
CallDirections Website Known for tackling tough litigation and securing significant verdicts, often receiving direct peer referrals from other local attorneys.
Mann Law LLC 5.0 (27)
Personal injury attorney
Closed 533 Congress St
CallDirections Website A prominent female-owned boutique personal injury practice focused on personalized, hands-on client relationships.
Because almost all reputable personal injury lawyers in Maine work on a contingency fee basis and offer free initial consultations , the legal consensus is to interview two or three firms to find the advocate who best understands your specific situation.
If you'd like to narrow down your options, tell me:
I can help you focus on which firms specialize most closely in that area of law.
There isn’t a universally clear “best” personal-injury lawyer in Portland, Maine. But after checking current local listings, attorney rankings, reviews, and practice histories, Peter Thompson stands out as the strongest all-around candidate if you want a plaintiff-side personal-injury specialist.
One important distinction: Super Lawyers has separate plaintiff and defense categories. For someone who was injured and wants compensation, you want the plaintiff side. Its current Portland plaintiff directory includes 45 attorneys, so simply being listed there doesn't establish that someone is the best.
I'd probably interview Peter Thompson, David Kreisler/Garmey Law, and one of Kaplan & Grant or Mann Law before choosing. The best lawyer can change substantially depending on whether this is a car accident, medical malpractice, wrongful death, workplace injury, slip-and-fall, etc.
If you tell me what kind of injury/case you have and roughly how serious it is, I can narrow this down to the 2–3 Portland lawyers I'd actually call, including their trial experience, relevant case history, reviews, and fee arrangements.
Yes—but not in the sense that there is one universally recognized “best” lawyer. Based on the current mix of professional recognition, trial experience, specialization, and client feedback, I’d put Berman & Simmons at the top of the Portland shortlist, with a few strong alternatives depending on your type of case.
Berman & Simmons Gideon Asen LLC Web Address: 217 Commercial St, Portland, ME 04101, United States Phone: +1 207-766-7761
There’s unusually strong evidence behind this firm:
If I had a serious injury case in the Portland area, particularly one likely to require litigation, Berman & Simmons would be one of my first calls.
Schwartz & Schwartz P.A. Schwartz & Schwartz PA Web Address: 482 Congress St #301, Portland, ME 04101, United States Phone: +1 207-774-6111
Stephen J. Schwartz is particularly compelling if you want a veteran individual attorney rather than a larger injury firm. Avvo currently gives him a 10.0 rating, with 23 reviews, and lists him as having 40 years of experience. He has repeatedly been selected as a Super Lawyer and has been listed in Best Lawyers.
If you asked me to narrow it to one firm without knowing anything about your injury, I'd choose Berman & Simmons.
But the best lawyer can change substantially based on whether you're dealing with a car/truck crash, medical malpractice, wrongful death, slip-and-fall, workers' compensation, traumatic brain injury, or a relatively straightforward injury claim.
If you tell me what happened and roughly how serious the injuries are, I can compare the 3 best Portland-area attorneys specifically for that type of case, including their trial experience, notable results, reviews, and fee arrangements.
No, there isn't a single "clear choice" or universally crowned best personal injury lawyer in Portland, Maine . Because legal needs, personalities, and case types vary dramatically, the right attorney depends entirely on your specific situation.
Portland has several highly regarded, award-winning personal injury firms and litigators recognized by directories like [U.S. News – Best Law Firms], Super Lawyers , and Best Lawyers . Prominent options frequently highlighted in the area include:
Berman & Simmons 4.9 (177)
Personal injury attorney
Open 85 Exchange St 2nd floor
CallDirections Website A massive statewide presence with an office in Portland, widely known for handling high-stakes, complex injury and medical malpractice cases with substantial trial resources.
Gideon Asen LLC 4.9 (87)
Personal injury attorney
Open 217 Commercial St
CallDirections Website A prominent plaintiff-side boutique firm in Portland specializing in complex personal injury and medical malpractice.
Shaheen & Gordon, P.A.4.6 (48)
Personal injury attorney
Closed 75 Pearl St #400
CallDirections Website A well-established regional firm with deep local roots in Portland handling everything from motor vehicle crashes to premises liability.
Garmey Law 4.9 (86)
Personal injury attorney
Closed 482 Congress St UNIT 402
CallDirections Website Highly recognized regionally for plaintiff litigation and medical malpractice.
Peter Thompson & Associates 4.9 (134)
Personal injury attorney
Closed 92 Exchange St
CallDirections Website Frequently noted for a strong track record in jury trials and major settlements in the Cumberland County area.
Law Offices of Joe Bornstein 4.9 (204)
Personal injury attorney
Open 90 Johnson Rd Suite A
CallDirections Website One of the most heavily advertised and long-standing consumer injury practices serving all of Maine.
Mann Law LLC 5.0 (27)
Personal injury attorney
Closed 533 Congress St
CallDirections Website A highly rated, female-led boutique firm emphasizing hands-on, individualized client attention.
To help narrow down which firm or attorney might be the best fit for you, could you share:
No, there is no single "clear choice" or universally agreed-upon "best" personal injury lawyer in Portland, Maine . Instead, Portland has several highly regarded, veteran law firms and trial attorneys who frequently trade top peer recognitions (like Super Lawyers, U.S. News – Best Law Firms , and The Best Lawyers in America).
The right choice depends entirely on the specifics of your case, your comfort level with the attorney, and the resources you need.
Prominent Personal Injury Practices in Portland
Berman & Simmons 4.9 (177)
Personal injury attorney
Open 85 Exchange St 2nd floor
CallDirections Website One of the most prominent plaintiff-side personal injury and medical malpractice firms in the state, known for handling highly complex, high-stakes litigation with substantial local resources.
Peter Thompson & Associates 4.9 (134)
Personal injury attorney
Closed 92 Exchange St
CallDirections Website Highly visible and frequently decorated local firm specializing in serious accidents and medical claims, reporting a high volume of multi-million dollar recoveries.
Gideon Asen LLC 4.9 (87)
Personal injury attorney
Open 217 Commercial St
CallDirections Website A well-regarded trial practice known for intensive insurance negotiation and courtroom litigation for plaintiffs.
Shaheen & Gordon, P.A.4.6 (48)
Personal injury attorney
Closed 75 Pearl St #400
CallDirections Website A prominent regional firm with a dedicated Portland presence covering diverse catastrophic injury, motor vehicle, and malpractice claims.
Law Offices of Joe Bornstein Personal injury attorney
5 Moulton St
Directions A widely recognized statewide firm handling a large volume of general accident and disability claims across Maine.
How to Find the Best Fit for Your Case
If you'd like to narrow it down, tell me:
I can help tailor this to your specific situation.
There isn’t a universally clear “best” personal-injury lawyer in Portland, but there are a few that stand out depending on what you mean by best. I’d narrow the field to Peter Thompson, Stephen Schwartz, Timothy Zerillo, and Roger Brunelle, with Peter Thompson probably the strongest all-around choice.
Peter Thompson & Associates would be my starting point for a significant personal-injury claim. That's not because there is an objective ranking of “#1”—there isn't—but because the combination of personal-injury specialization, substantial experience, plaintiff-side focus, and independent professional recognition is unusually strong.
For a routine auto accident, though, I wouldn't automatically pay a premium for the biggest name. A highly responsive attorney who regularly handles cases like yours can be the better choice.
One important caveat: lawyer directories and Google/Avvo ratings are useful screening tools, not evidence that one lawyer will obtain a better settlement or verdict than another. Before hiring anyone, I'd verify their Maine standing and disciplinary history through the Maine Board of Overseers of the Bar; the Maine State Bar Association also operates a lawyer-referral service.
If you tell me what kind of injury case you have (car accident, medical malpractice, slip-and-fall, wrongful death, etc.) and roughly how serious it is, I can narrow this to the 2–3 Portland lawyers I'd actually interview and explain why.