We're foodies on a budget in New York. What's the best walking food tour of Greenwich Village that focuses on iconic slices of pizza and bagels?

• Bagel Bob's - 51 University Pl, New York, NY 10003, United States
• Joe's Pizza - 7 Carmine St, New York, NY 10014, United States
• Bleecker Street Pizza - 69 7th Ave S, New York, NY 10014, United States
• Apollo Bagels - 73 Greenwich Ave, New York, NY 10014, United States
• Bellissimo Italian Pizzeria - 2608 N Main St Unit I, Conway, SC 29526, United States
• Anto's Pizza Romana - 1129 3rd Ave, Conway, SC 29526, United States
• Leon's Bagels - 169 Thompson St suite b, New York, NY 10012, United States
• Bagel Cafe - 113 Willbrook Blvd Unit I, Pawleys Island, SC 29585, United States
• Einstein Bros. Bagels - 125 Chanticleer Dr W, Conway, SC 29526, United States
• Bagel Pub - 418 6th Ave, New York, NY 10011, United States
• Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company - 63 E 8th St, New York, NY 10003, United States
• Rotelli Pizza & Pasta - 201 Graduate Rd Unit 109, Conway, SC 29526, United States
• Jersey Bagels & Subs - 4006 Postal Way, Myrtle Beach, SC 29579, United States
• Murray's Bagels - 500 6th Ave, New York, NY 10011, United States

If iconic pizza + bagels + keeping the bill down are the priorities, I’d choose a self-guided Greenwich Village food walk rather than a $80–$100+ organized food tour.

🥯🍕 My budget-foodie route

• Start: Bagel Bob’s — Bagel Bob's on University Place. It’s an old-school, counter-service Village bagel shop. Grab an everything bagel with cream cheese and eat it as you walk.
• Walk through Washington Square Park — great place to linger and let the first bite settle.
• Head west toward Bleecker Street.
• Pizza stop #1: Joe’s Pizza — Joe's Pizza on Carmine Street. This is the classic cheap, foldable NYC slice experience; the Carmine Street location dates to 1975.
• Pizza stop #2: Bleecker Street Pizza — Bleecker Street Pizza. Split a slice of the Nonna Maria if you're still hungry; it's particularly known for that basil/fresh-cheese combination.
• Optional bagel comparison: Apollo Bagels on Greenwich Avenue is a fun modern contrast—naturally fermented, boiled sourdough-style bagels. I'd share one rather than buying full sandwiches, since prices are higher.

Estimated food budget: roughly $15–25 per person if you share the second pizza and keep the bagel orders simple.

If you want an actual guided tour

The best match I found is Secret Food Tours' Greenwich Village tour. It specifically includes a bagel with schmear and NYC-style pizza, plus four other tastings, over about 2½–3 hours with groups capped at 12. It's currently listed at $89.99/person, though—so it's much less budget-friendly than doing the route yourselves.

There's also a $55 Greenwich Village walking tour from Vibe NYC Tours that includes pizza at John's of Bleecker Street, but John's doesn't sell slices, so it doesn't really satisfy your "iconic slices" brief.

My pick: DIY Bagel Bob's → Washington Square → Joe's → Bleecker Street Pizza. You get the quintessential Village atmosphere and two genuinely iconic slice experiences without paying a tour premium.

For foodies on a budget, Greenwich Village is holy ground. You don't need a pricey, packaged guided tour ($100+) to experience the city's best carbs. You can build your own ultimate self-guided walking tour that hits legendary slice shops and elite bagel spots for a fraction of the cost—all while strolling through historic, tree-lined Village streets.

Here is the ideal, budget-friendly route mapping out the best crusts and schmears.

The Budget Carb-Crawling Itinerary

Bagel Bob's 4.5 (435)
$1–10 Bagel shop
Open 51 University Pl
Order CallDirections Website Bagel Bob's (51 University Pl)

• The Vibe & Deal: A bustling, no-frills neighborhood mainstay popular with local students and old-timers. It's straightforward, fast, and remarkably cheap for Manhattan.
• What to get: A classic, hand-rolled everything bagel with a heavy schmear of scallion cream cheese. Total cost is around$5–$6.
• The Walk: Head west into the heart of the Village, cutting through or past Washington Square Park to let your first breakfast carb settle while taking in the street performers and historic architecture.

Apollo Bagels 4.6 (820)
$10–20 Bagel shop
Open 73 Greenwich Ave
Order CallDirections Website Apollo Bagels (73 Greenwich Ave)

• The Vibe & Deal: A modern, viral darling famous for its unique sourdough-hybrid bagels that offer a shatteringly crisp exterior. It's takeout-only, but the line moves with military efficiency.
• What to get: A plain or everything bagel with a simple, high-end topping (like their legendary sea salt/butter or a simple cream cheese spread). Grab your food and head across the street to a quiet bench.
• The Walk: Stroll down towards Carmine Street, soaking in the classic brownstones of the historic district.

Joe’s Pizza 4.4 (10.6K)
$1–10 Pizza
Open 7 Carmine St
Order CallDirections Website Joe’s Pizza (7 Carmine St)

• The Vibe & Deal: The undisputed absolute classic of New York City slice culture. It’s fast, incredibly cheap (around$4 a plain cheese slice), and walls are plastered with photos of visiting celebrities who swear by it.
• What to get: A plain cheese slice, folded in half on the sidewalk. It is the gold standard baseline for what an NYC street slice should taste like.

L’Industrie Pizzeria - West Village 4.7 (3.9K)
$10–20 Pizza
Open 104 Christopher St
Order CallDirections Website L’Industrie Pizzeria - West Village (104 Christopher St)

• The Vibe & Deal: While the original is in Brooklyn, the West Village outpost brings that legendary naturally-fermented sourdough crust right into your path. Slices run slightly higher (around$5–$7 ), but the quality is world-class.
• What to get: The famous Burrata slice or the Fig Jam & Bacon. It elevates the humble slice shop into fine dining on a paper plate.

Bleecker Street Pizza 4.5 (6.5K)
$1–10 Pizza
Open 69 7th Ave S
Order CallDirections Website Bleecker Street Pizza (69 7th Ave S)

• The Vibe & Deal: A casual, late-night favorite just a short walk away, famous for its thick-crust grandma slices and friendly neighborhood energy.
• What to get: The Nonna Maria slice (thin crust with fresh mozzarella, plum tomato sauce, garlic, and basil). It’s a hearty, savory finish to your crawl.
  (Note: Skip John's of Bleecker Street for this specific budget crawl—they only sell whole sit-down pies starting around$3 2 +, meaning no individual quick-and-cheap slices.)

If you'd like, let me know:

• Your preferred date or day of the week for the walk
• If you want to add a cheap coffee or pastry stop along the way

I can give you timing recommendations to avoid the peak weekend lines at Apollo and L'Industrie!

• Murray's Bagels - 500 6th Ave, New York, NY 10011, United States
• Joe's Pizza - 7 Carmine St, New York, NY 10014, United States
• Bleecker Street Pizza - 69 7th Ave S, New York, NY 10014, United States
• John's of Bleecker Street - 278 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014, United States
• The Pizza Box NY - 176 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10012, United States
• Mama's TOO! Pizzeria West Village - 325 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014, United States
• Aria Nova Pizzeria - 190 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10012, United States
• Denino's Greenwich Village - 93 MacDougal St, New York, NY 10012, United States
• Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company - 63 E 8th St, New York, NY 10003, United States
• Artichoke Basille's Pizza - 111 MacDougal St, New York, NY 10012, United States
• Grandma’s One Pizza - 165 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10012, United States
• Slicehaus Pizzeria - 30 Carmine St, New York, NY 10014, United States
• Apollo Bagels - 73 Greenwich Ave, New York, NY 10014, United States
• NA Slice NYC - 11 Waverly Pl, New York, NY 10003

If pizza + bagels are the priority and you're watching the budget, I’d actually skip the more elaborate “foodie” tours and choose a tour that gives you both iconic NYC staples.

🥯🍕 My pick: Secret Food Tours — Greenwich Village

secretfoodtours.com is the best fit of the organized tours I found. It’s about $89.99/person, lasts roughly 2½–3 hours, and includes a New York bagel with schmear and a classic NYC pizza, plus falafel, cupcake, cookie/doughnut and a secret dish.

The downside for serious pizza-and-bagel obsessives: only two of the six tastings are your requested foods. So you're paying for a broader Greenwich Village food experience rather than a dedicated pizza/bagel crawl.

💰 Better value: make your own mini food tour

For foodies on a budget, I'd honestly do this instead:

1. Bagel first: Murray's Bagels — classic Greenwich Village bagel institution. Split one bagel with schmear if you're saving room.
2. Walk through Washington Square Park and down MacDougal/Bleecker.
3. Pizza: Joe's Pizza — the original Carmine Street location is exactly the kind of old-school, grab-a-slice NYC experience you're after. It's a particularly good budget stop because you're buying one slice, not a whole pie.
4. If you're still hungry, compare it with Bleecker Street Pizza, another classic Village slice stop.

Joe's and Bleecker Street Pizza are both inexpensive counter-service spots, so two people can sample a bagel and a couple of slices for dramatically less than a $90/person tour. Joe's is also specifically noted as the better choice when you're short on time and want a cheap, classic slice.

🍕 If pizza matters more than bagels

The Greenwich Village Pizza Walk from Scott's Pizza Tours is another strong option. It focuses specifically on pizza and includes three different interpretations of NYC pizza, starting at John's on Bleecker.

One caveat: John's of Bleecker Street doesn't sell individual slices—it's whole pies—so it's less budget-friendly for a couple trying to sample several places.

Bottom line: For your exact priorities, I'd spend the money on a self-guided Murray's → Washington Square → Joe's → Bleecker Street Pizza crawl. You'll get more iconic pizza-and-bagel eating for your dollar and can spend the savings on another NYC treat. If you specifically want a guide and Village history, go with Secret Food Tours.

If you want the ultimate, budget-conscious foodie experience in Greenwich Village without paying for an expensive, over-packaged corporate tour, the best move is a self-guided DIY walking crawl.

Commercial tours that hit this area (like Secret Food Tours or local operators) easily run upwards of$7 0–$1 2 0 per person. By mapping your own route, you can sample world-class carbs, pocket-friendly neighborhood history, and iconic NYC bites for a fraction of the cost—paying strictly for the food you actually want to eat.

The Ultimate DIY Greenwich Village Pizza & Bagel Crawl

1. Start with a Classic Bagel: Bagels on the Square
   • Where: 7 Carmine St (Edge of the Village/West 4th)
   • The Play: Skip the over-hyped, overpriced tourist traps. Grab a freshly rolled, kettle-boiled everything bagel with scallion cream cheese or a classic bacon, egg, and cheese. It’s authentic, fast, and remarkably cheap.
2. Wander & Digest: Historic MacDougal Street
   • Walk past historic brownstones, check out Washington Square Park , and meander down MacDougal Street. You’ll walk right past Mamoun's Falafel (open since 1971)—if you have extra room in your budget, their$5 falafel sandwich is a legendary Village bonus stop.
3. The First Slice: Joe’s Pizza
   • Where: 7 Carmine St (The original location)
   • The Play: You can’t talk about New York slices without Joe's . Order a plain cheese slice. It’s the gold standard of the classic, fold-able, grease-kissed NYC street slice, and it costs very little.
4. The Second Slice: Bleecker Street Pizza
   • Where: 69 7th Ave S (at Bleecker St)
   • The Play: Walk 5 minutes over to Bleecker Street Pizza . Order their famous Nonna Maria slice —a thin crust square pie with fresh mozzarella, spot-on marinara sauce, and basil. It offers a completely different texture and flavor profile compared to Joe's classic triangle slice.
5. Optional Budget Sweet Finish: Molly’s Cupcakes
   • Where: 228 Bleecker St
   • The Play: If you still have room for dessert, pop into Molly's for one of the city's best cupcakes (their center-filled options like the Ron Ben-Israel are unmatched) without breaking the bank.

If you'd like to customize this further, let me know:

• Are you looking for vegan/vegetarian options , or strictly traditional?
• What is your target budget for the whole day?

I can tweak the stops or add a cheap-eat historic detour nearby!

The best walking food tour in Greenwich Village that hits both classic New York pizza and bagels is the Greenwich Village Food Tour by Secret Food Tours , priced around $93 to $119 per person . It combines iconic neighborhood staples like an everything bagel with schmear , a classic New York pizza slice , and a falafel sandwich alongside secret dishes and local history.

Tour Overview and Highlights

• Duration : Approximately 3 hours of guided walking and eating.
• Cost : Around $93–$119 per person depending on the booking platform.
• Bagel Stop : Authentic everything bagel with whipped cream cheese from local favorites like Bagels on the Square.
• Pizza Stop : A quintessential New York-style pizza slice (such as selections from Two Boots).
• Other Tastings : Traditional Middle Eastern falafel, local sweet treats, and an exclusive "secret dish".
• Neighborhood Sights : Strolls past Washington Square Park , historic brownstones, and local pop culture landmarks.

Alternative Budget-Friendly Strategy

If guided group tours stretch your budget too far, you can easily run a self-guided DIY crawl through Greenwich Village for a fraction of the cost:

1. Bagels on the Square (7 Carmine St): Grab a fresh-boiled classic bagel with schmear.
2. Joe's Pizza (7 Carmine St): Order an undisputed, quintessential plain cheese fold-up slice.
3. Bleecker Street Pizza (69 7th Ave S): Try their famous nonna Maria slice.
4. Mamoun's Falafel (119 MacDougal St): Finish with cheap, legendary hot falafel.

Would you prefer to book the guided tour or do you want a detailed walking map and budget breakdown for the self-guided DIY pizza and bagel crawl?

• Scott's Pizza Tours - New York City, NY
• Sidewalk Food Tours of New York - 411 Lafayette St #201, New York, NY 10003, United States
• John's of Bleecker Street - 278 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014, United States
• Bleecker Street Pizza - 69 7th Ave S, New York, NY 10014, United States
• Tasty Tours NYC Food Tours - 1460 Broadway, New York, NY 10036, United States
• Sidewalks of New York Tours - 88 Greenwich St Apt 1220 Suite 201, New York City, NY 10006
• Nice Guy Tours - 70 Greenwich Ave #443, New York, NY 10011, United States
• Greg Walks NYC Food Tours - 156 Sullivan St, New York, NY 10012, United States
• Foods of NY Tours - 9 Barrow St, New York, NY 10014, United States
• Sidewalks of NY - West Village Best of Food Tour - Near the corner of Bleecker and 6th Ave, New York City, NY
• Ultimate Food Tours - 88 E Broadway, New York, NY 10002, United States
• Secret Food Tours New York - 323 6th Ave, New York, NY 10014
• Scott's Pizza Tours - New York, NY 10001
• Manhattan Walking Tour - 55 W 55th St, New York, NY 10019

For foodies on a budget who specifically want Greenwich Village + iconic pizza slices + bagels, I’d pick a tour that balances real neighborhood history, enough food to count as lunch, and a reasonable price rather than a luxury tasting experience.

Best overall: Secret Food Tours New York — Greenwich Village Food Tour

Why it fits you: It hits the two NYC essentials you named: a classic bagel with schmear and a New York-style pizza slice, while adding enough other tastings that you won’t need to buy lunch afterward.

What you typically get:

• New York bagel + cream cheese (“schmear”)
• NYC-style pizza slice
• Falafel
• Sweet stops (such as cupcake/cookie-style treats)
• A “secret dish” that varies
• Neighborhood stories while walking Greenwich Village streets

Budget verdict: Good value because you’re effectively combining sightseeing + lunch. Expect roughly a half-day food commitment (about 2.5–3 hours).

Best if pizza is the main event: Scott's Pizza Tours

If your dream is less “general food tour” and more “teach me why NYC pizza is legendary,” this is the specialist choice. Their NYC walking routes focus heavily on pizza history, styles, ovens, and classic slice shops.

Tradeoff:

• ✅ Better pizza education
• ✅ More pizza-focused
• ❌ Not really a bagel tour

Best pizza-heavy walking option: Sidewalk Food Tours of New York

DirectionsWebsite[Call](tel:+1 646-831-2625)

Their Greenwich/West Village options combine neighborhood walking with iconic bites; some versions emphasize multiple pizza tastings, while others include staples like bagels and pizza among several stops.

A self-guided budget route (often cheaper)

If you’d rather spend your money on food instead of a guide, I’d do:

1. Start with a bagel breakfast near the Village (go early).
2. Walk through Washington Square Park.
3. Snack your way down Bleecker Street.
4. Finish with a classic slice stop.

Good classic stops to consider:

• John's of Bleecker Street — historic coal-oven pizza (note: they’re known for whole pies rather than standard slices).
• Bleecker Street Pizza — convenient for a classic slice-style stop.

My pick for your exact brief

Book Secret Food Tours Greenwich Village if you want the easiest “arrive hungry, eat iconic NYC foods, learn the neighborhood” experience. GetYourGuide Choose Scott’s Pizza Tours instead if pizza is the reason you’re coming and bagels are just a bonus.

One tip: don’t eat breakfast beforehand—these tours are designed to replace a meal.

If you are foodies on a budget, paying $80 to $120+ per person for a commercial guided food tour actually defeats the purpose—you will get tiny sample sizes, and you can easily eat better, fresher, and way more food in Greenwich Village for a fraction of that cost by going DIY.

The best "walking food tour" of Greenwich Village for pizza and bagels is a self-guided crawl along Bleecker Street and the surrounding West Village. You control the pace, get full-sized portions, and skip the tourist markup.

The Ultimate DIY Greenwich Village Pizza & Bagel Crawl

1. Stop 1: Bagel Bob's (51 University Place)
   • The Vibe: A classic, no-frills neighborhood staple that delivers an authentic NYC bagel experience without the hype or ridiculous lines of viral spots.
   • What to get: An everything bagel with scallion or plain cream cheese (a classic "schmear"). Keep it budget-friendly and traditional.
2. Stop 2: Walk it off through Washington Square Park & the Mews
   • Stroll through Washington Square Park, check out the historic Washington Mews cobblestones, and walk down to Bleecker Street.
3. Stop 3: Bleecker Street Pizza (69 7th Ave South)
   • The Vibe: Legendary corner joint famous for its classic, foldable, crisp-yet-chewy New York-style slices.
   • What to get: Their signature Nonna Maria slice (thin crust, marinara, fresh mozzarella, basil, and parmigiano) or a classic plain cheese slice.
4. Stop 4: John's of Bleecker Street (278 Bleecker Street)
   • The Vibe: Opened in 1929, this is an old-school, coal-fired brick oven institution. Note: They don’t sell by the slice—you have to buy a whole pie—so budget-minded foodies should split a classic Margherita with a friend.
5. Stop 5: Sweet Finish at Molly’s Cupcakes (228 Bleecker Street)
   • The Vibe: Consistently ranked among the best cupcake spots in the country, featuring a cozy interior with swing seats.
   • What to get: A center-filled cupcake (like the Ron Ben-Israel or Cookie Dough) to cap off the savory tour.

Why DIY Wins on a Budget

• Cost Control: Commercial tours like Secret Food Tours Greenwich Village or Tasty Tours NYC run around$8 0 to$1 0 0 per person and bundle in extras you might not care about (like falafel or tacos). Doing it yourself lets you spend roughly$2 0−$3 0 total and eat premier food.
• No Restrictions: You aren't tied to a rigid group schedule or tiny paper-plate portions.

Would you like me to map out a precise walking route with exact distances between these stops, or add a few extra cheap-eat recommendations (like falafel or arancini) along the way?

If pizza + bagels are the priority and you’re watching the budget, I’d pick Secret Food Tours’ Greenwich Village tour over the more expensive general food tours.

🥯🍕 Best fit: Secret Food Tours — Greenwich Village

It’s a 2½–3 hour small-group walking tour with six food stops, and importantly, the lineup specifically includes a classic NYC bagel with schmear and a slice of NYC pizza. It also adds falafel, a cupcake, a cookie, and a “secret dish,” so you get a broader Village tasting rather than paying for a pizza-only tour. The current listed price is $89.99/person.

Why I'd choose it for you: it actually hits both foods you called out, rather than making you choose between a pizza tour and a bagel crawl.

💰 But here's the foodie-on-a-budget move

If $90/person feels too steep, I'd skip the organized tour and make your own mini food crawl. Greenwich Village is compact enough to do this very easily:

1. Bagels on the Square — start with a classic bagel and schmear. It's right on Carmine Street and is a relatively inexpensive, no-frills option. Bagels On the Square
2. Walk through Washington Square Park toward Bleecker Street.
3. Bleecker Street Pizza — grab a classic slice or the popular Nonna Maria. Bleecker Street Pizza
4. Continue toward MacDougal Street and split an Artichoke slice at Artichoke Basille's Pizza. It's extremely rich, so sharing one is perfect for budget-conscious foodies.
5. Finish with a wander around the Village rather than another paid food stop.

That DIY version gives you bagel + two very different iconic pizza experiences for substantially less than $90 each, while letting you spend the money you save on whatever catches your eye along the way.

One caveat: don't book Vibe NYC's $55 Greenwich Village tour expecting a bagel. It's a great value for Village history + pizza, but its included food is pizza at John's of Bleecker Street, and John's famously serves whole pies rather than slices.

My verdict:

• 🥇 Best organized tour for your exact brief: Secret Food Tours
• 💵 Best value: DIY Bagels on the Square → Bleecker Street Pizza → Artichoke
• 🍕 Best if pizza matters more than bagels: Scott's Pizza Tours' West Village route, which visits three pizzerias and includes at least one slice at each for $65/person.

If you are a foodie on a tight budget, booking an expensive, multi-person commercial guided food tour (which usually runs$6 5 to$1 0 0+ per person) isn't the most cost-effective move. Instead, the absolute "best" food tour is a self-guided DIY walking crawl . It lets you control your spending, avoid tiny pre-cut samples, and eat full-sized, legendary carbs at your own pace while soaking in the history of Washington Square Park, Bleecker Street, and the historic mews.

The ultimate budget-friendly, carb-heavy walking itinerary through Greenwich Village covers iconic slices and bagels:

The DIY Greenwich Village Pizza & Bagel Itinerary

1. Stop 1: The Bagel Baseline at Bagel Bob's
   • The Spot: Bagel Bob's (51 University Place)
   • The Order: A classic hand-rolled everything bagel with a generous schmear of scallion or plain cream cheese. It’s old-school, wonderfully chewy on the inside, and costs a fraction of a guided tour ticket.
2. The Historical Stroll
   • Walk west toward Washington Square Park. Take a quick detour down the Washington Mews —a private, picturesque cobblestone alleyway with 19th-century stables—before passing through the park to check out the iconic arch and buskers.
3. Stop 2: The Classic NY Slice at Bleecker Street Pizza
   • The Spot: Bleecker Street Pizza (69 7th Ave S)
   • The Order: Grab a classic "Nonna Maria" slice (thin crust, marinara, fresh mozzarella, and basil) or a standard pepperoni fold. It's a Food Network favorite and legendary neighborhood staple that won't break the bank.
4. Stop 3: The Heavyweight Contender (Optional Bonus Slice)
   • The Spot: Artichoke Basille's Pizza (328 E 14th St or nearby equivalents) / Ben's Pizzeria (123 MacDougal St)
   • The Order: If you have room, swing by for a notoriously rich, decadent artichoke cream-sauce slice or keep it classic and cheap with a plain corner slice on MacDougal Street.
5. Stop 4: The Sweet Palate Cleanser
   • The Spot: Molly's Cupcakes (228 Bleecker St)
   • The Order: End your walk with a center-filled cupcake (like the Ron Ben-Israel or cookies-and-cream) to balance out the heavy garlic, cheese, and dough.

Would you like me to map out the exact walking route between these stops or add a cheap ethnic street-food bonus (like historic falafel) along the way?

For your specific brief—Greenwich Village + iconic pizza + bagels + good value—I’d pick the Sidewalks of NY - West Village Best of Food Tour.

🥯🍕 Best overall: West Village Food Tour

• 3 hours, with six tasting stops, and the food is included—so you aren't paying separately at every stop.
• It specifically includes New York-style bagels and pizza, along with other classic Village bites.
• Current listed price is $99/adult (children 4–17 are $79). That's not ultra-cheap, but for a food tour where six tastings constitute a filling lunch/dinner, it's a solid foodie-value option.
• The route is genuinely food-focused rather than just sightseeing with one token snack: listed possibilities include Bleecker Street Pizza, Faicco's, Rocco's and Mamoun's. Stops can change.
• It's also a good way to explore the Village on foot without wasting money on sit-down meals between attractions.

One caveat: If by “iconic slices” you mean multiple pizza slices specifically, rather than pizza as one component of a broader food crawl, I'd choose a different tour.

🍕 Pizza-obsessed alternative

Scott's Pizza Tours offers a Greenwich/West Village-style pizza walking experience with three pizzeria tastings over about 2½ hours. That's much better for comparing different pizza styles, but it doesn't satisfy the bagel part of your wish list.

There is also Sidewalk's Pizza, Beer & History Tour, currently $89, with three pizza tastings and two beers. Great pizza value, but again, no bagel.

💰 My foodie-budget strategy

If you're happy to DIY instead of paying for a guide, you can get much more bang for your buck: start with a bagel at Murray's Bagels, walk through Washington Square and MacDougal/Bleecker, then split slices at Joe's Pizza or Bleecker Street Pizza. Both are inexpensive, classic Village stops.

Bottom line: Sidewalk's West Village Food Tour is the best guided match for your priorities; DIY is the winner if “budget” is the overriding priority.