As a creative strategist , running an effective brainstorming and ideation session isn't about sitting in a room waiting for lightning to strike—it’s about engineering the conditions for breakthrough thinking. The best methods combine strategic rigor with divergent, messy creativity.

Here are the top methods used by leading strategists to drive high-impact ideation:

• Crazy Eights : A fast-paced sketching exercise where participants fold a piece of paper into eight rectangles and have just 8 minutes (1 minute per panel) to sketch or write eight distinct ideas. This forces speed and stops people from over-editing their initial thoughts.
• SCAMPER : A prompt-based technique where you take an existing product, campaign, or framework and systematically apply seven lenses: S ubstitute, C ombine, A dapt, M odify, P ut to another use, E liminate, and R everse. It’s a bulletproof way to iterate on tired concepts.
• How Might We (HMW) : Framing your core strategic challenges as open-ended questions starting with "How might we..." This shifts the mindset from a dead-end problem statement into an invitation for collaborative problem-solving.
• Worst Possible Idea (Reverse Brainstorming) : Ask the room to intentionally generate the absolute worst, most disastrous, or most unfeasible ideas possible. It instantly breaks the ice, relieves the pressure of "sounding smart," and often uncovers hidden assumptions you can flip into brilliant solutions.
• Silent Brainwriting (Brainswarming) : Instead of shouting out ideas (which lets the loudest voices dominate), team members write ideas silently on sticky notes or a shared digital board for 10 minutes, then group and build on them together. This guarantees equal input from introverts and extroverts alike.

If you want, I can:

Provide a step-by-step agenda for a 60-minute ideation workshop Share tips on how to filter and prioritize the ideas after the session Give examples of how to handle difficult or dominant personalities in the room

For a creative strategist, the best ideation sessions usually aren't about simply “getting everyone to brainstorm.” They’re about creating the right conditions for divergent thinking, then deliberately narrowing toward strategically useful ideas.

I’d use a mix of these methods:

1. Start with a sharp “How Might We?” question

Before generating anything, reframe the challenge as an opportunity.

Instead of:

“How do we make this campaign better?” Try:

“How might we make people feel that this brand understands them before they even realize they have a need?” A good prompt should be specific enough to create direction, but open enough to permit surprising answers. SAP, for example, recommends establishing a clear problem statement before beginning 6-3-5 brainwriting.

Strategist's trick: Create 3–5 different framings of the same problem and brainstorm against each one. You'll often discover that the framing, rather than the ideation technique, is the biggest source of breakthrough ideas.

---

2. Brainwriting before brainstorming

This is one of my strongest recommendations for teams.

Instead of immediately asking everyone to shout ideas into the room, give people 5–10 minutes to generate ideas silently and independently.

The classic 6-3-5 method has six people write three ideas in five minutes, then pass them to another participant, who builds on them. A complete cycle can generate up to 108 idea entries in about 30 minutes.

Why it's valuable:

• Everyone contributes.
• Senior/loud personalities don't dominate.
• People don't have to wait for their turn.
• Participants can build on ideas rather than merely react to whoever spoke last.
• It creates a much larger raw pool before the group starts judging.

Research comparing ideation approaches has found advantages for structured brainwriting, including hybrid 6-3-5 approaches.

Best for: campaign concepts, positioning, product ideas, content territories, brand activations.

---

3. SCAMPER for pushing beyond the obvious

When the team has already generated some ideas but they're feeling predictable, use SCAMPER.

Take an existing idea and ask:

• S — Substitute: What could we replace?
• C — Combine: What could we merge?
• A — Adapt: What could we borrow from somewhere else?
• M — Modify: What could we exaggerate, shrink, amplify, or change?
• P — Put to another use: Could this solve a completely different problem?
• E — Eliminate: What could we remove?
• R — Rearrange: What happens if we reverse the sequence or assumptions?

SCAMPER is specifically designed as a set of provocative lenses for transforming existing products, services, problems, or ideas.

Example: If you're brainstorming a coffee brand campaign:

“What if we eliminate the coffee?” That seemingly ridiculous question could lead to an idea about the ritual, conversation, productivity, or social identity surrounding coffee rather than the beverage itself.

That's often where strategic creativity gets interesting.

---

4. “Worst idea first”

This is particularly useful when a team is being overly cautious.

Ask everyone to intentionally generate:

“What is the worst possible idea we could launch?” Give them 3–5 minutes.

Then ask:

“What makes these ideas terrible?” And finally:

“Is there anything inside these terrible ideas that could actually be interesting?” It lowers evaluation anxiety and gets people comfortable being unconventional.

You can also reverse it:

“What would we do if we weren't allowed to be boring?”

---

5. Constraint-based ideation

Counterintuitively, constraints can make brainstorming better.

Instead of:

“Come up with a campaign.” Try:

• The campaign can't use video.
• It has to cost less than $10K.
• It must work without paid media.
• It has to be understandable in five seconds.
• It must involve customers.
• It can only use one visual asset.
• It must work globally.
• It has to make people physically do something.

Then generate ideas.

Research on Six Thinking Hats has also found that structured thinking modes and time pressure can increase the number and flexibility of ideas.

Strategic benefit: Constraints force the team to solve the actual problem instead of producing generic “big ideas.”

---

6. Borrow from another category

One of my favorite techniques for strategists is cross-industry inspiration.

Ask:

“How would [Netflix / Nike / a luxury hotel / a gaming company / a political campaign / a museum / a streetwear brand] solve this?” Then deliberately transfer the principle—not the execution.

For example:

“What could a luxury hotel teach us about onboarding users?” You aren't copying hospitality. You're looking for behavioral or experience principles that can be transplanted into your problem.

This is especially powerful for brand strategy because it breaks the team out of category conventions.

---

7. Six Thinking Hats for perspective switching

Once you have ideas, deliberately force the group to look at them from different perspectives.

The classic framework uses different “hats” for different modes of thinking—for example, factual analysis, emotion, caution, and optimism.

For a creative strategy session, I might simplify it to:

• Data: What does the evidence tell us?
• Human: Would anyone actually care?
• Dream: What could this become if we went much bigger?
• Risk: Why might this fail?
• Brand: Does this feel uniquely us?
• Provocation: What would make it 10× more interesting?

This is particularly useful after divergent ideation, because it prevents the team from killing an idea prematurely with one person's criticism.

---

8. Crazy 8s / rapid visual ideation

Give everyone a sheet divided into eight sections.

8 minutes. 8 ideas.

One minute per idea.

Crucially, ask people to sketch rather than explain.

This works particularly well for:

• Campaign executions
• Social concepts
• Packaging
• Experiences
• Digital products
• Visual identities
• Content formats

The time constraint prevents people from polishing their first idea for 20 minutes.

---

9. “And / or” rather than “Yes, but”

During the generative phase, establish one rule:

Don't say “yes, but.” Say “yes, and…” or “what if…” “That's impossible because…” is useful later.

During divergence, it kills momentum.

For example:

Person A: “What if the brand let customers design the product?”

Person B: “That would be operationally impossible.”

Instead:

Person B: “What if customers could design the next campaign instead?”

Now you're building rather than defending.

---

10. Forced connections

Put two unrelated concepts together and make the team find the connection.

For example:

Luxury brand × TikTok creator economy Banking × dating apps Fast food × subscription services Museum × gaming Then ask:

“What principle from A could fundamentally change B?” This is excellent for finding unexpected strategic territories, rather than simply generating executions.

---

11. Diverge → cluster → evaluate → develop

This is probably the most important overall structure.

Don't mix ideation and evaluation.

A strong session looks like:

Phase 1 — Frame

10–15 min

Define the problem, audience, insight and creative challenge.

Phase 2 — Diverge

20–40 min

Brainwriting, SCAMPER, Crazy 8s, provocations, forced connections.

No judging.

Phase 3 — Cluster

10–15 min

Group similar ideas into territories.

You'll often discover that 50 ideas actually represent 5–7 underlying concepts.

Phase 4 — Converge

15–20 min

Evaluate against explicit criteria:

• Strategic relevance
• Audience relevance
• Distinctiveness
• Brand fit
• Feasibility
• Cultural potential
• Ability to scale

Research on team creativity emphasizes that generating ideas isn't enough; teams also need effective processes for evaluating and selecting them.

Phase 5 — Develop

Take the best 2–3 territories and ask:

“How could we make this dramatically more interesting?” That's where the strategist becomes particularly valuable.

---

A high-performing 60-minute session

If I were facilitating a creative strategy workshop, I'd probably run:

0–10 min — Context + challenge Share the insight, audience tension and “How Might We?”

10–15 min — Individual provocation Everyone independently writes 5 ideas.

15–25 min — 6-3-5-style brainwriting Build on each other's ideas silently.

25–35 min — Provocation round Use SCAMPER + constraints + “worst idea.”

35–45 min — Cluster Group ideas into strategic territories.

45–52 min — Vote Everyone independently selects their strongest concepts.

52–60 min — Develop Take the top 2–3 and turn them into rough creative territories.

The key principle is:

Don't ask people to “be creative.” Give them different cognitive jobs. Generate → distort → combine → challenge → cluster → choose → develop.

That's much more reliable than putting six people around a table and saying, “Okay, guys, any ideas?”

“What principle from A could fundamentally change B?” This is excellent for finding unexpected strategic territories, rather than simply generating executions.

---

11. Diverge → cluster → evaluate → develop

This is probably the most important overall structure.

Don't mix ideation and evaluation.

A strong session looks like:

Phase 1 — Frame

10–15 min

Define the problem, audience, insight and creative challenge.

Phase 2 — Diverge

20–40 min

Brainwriting, SCAMPER, Crazy 8s, provocations, forced connections.

No judging.

Phase 3 — Cluster

10–15 min

Group similar ideas into territories.

You'll often discover that 50 ideas actually represent 5–7 underlying concepts.

Phase 4 — Converge

15–20 min

Evaluate against explicit criteria:

• Strategic relevance
• Audience relevance
• Distinctiveness
• Brand fit
• Feasibility
• Cultural potential
• Ability to scale

Research on team creativity emphasizes that generating ideas isn't enough; teams also need effective processes for evaluating and selecting them.

A creative strategist’s best brainstorming sessions usually combine divergent thinking (generating many possibilities) with convergent thinking (selecting and refining the strongest ideas). The most effective methods create structure without making creativity feel constrained.

1. Start with a strong creative brief or “How Might We” question

Before generating ideas, define the challenge in a way that opens possibilities.

Instead of:

• “How do we sell more products?”

Try:

• “How might we make customers feel like they discovered something they can’t live without?”
• “How might we turn a boring category into a cultural movement?”

A good prompt:

• Focuses on the audience/problem, not the solution
• Creates tension or curiosity
• Is broad enough for exploration but specific enough to guide ideas

2. Brainwriting (better than traditional brainstorming for many teams)

Instead of having everyone shout ideas, participants silently write ideas first, then build on each other’s concepts.

Why it works:

• Prevents the loudest person from dominating
• Gives quieter thinkers room to contribute
• Produces more independent ideas before group influence kicks in

A simple format:

1. Give everyone 5 minutes to write 5 ideas.
2. Pass ideas around.
3. Each person adds, improves, or challenges what they receive.
4. Discuss the strongest concepts.

Brainwriting is commonly used as a way to reduce groupthink and increase participation.

3. Mind mapping for strategic exploration

Start with a central idea and branch outward into themes, associations, audiences, emotions, channels, behaviors, and opportunities.

Example:

Core challenge: “Make fitness more appealing”

Branches:

• Culture → communities, identity, trends
• Emotion → confidence, belonging, achievement
• Product → features, experiences
• Audience → beginners, athletes, families
• Partnerships → creators, brands, events

Mind mapping is especially useful early in ideation when you are exploring a broad landscape.

4. SCAMPER for improving or reinventing existing ideas

SCAMPER is useful when you already have a product, campaign, brand, or experience and want fresh angles. It prompts teams to:

• Substitute — What could we replace?
• Combine — What could we merge?
• Adapt — What could we borrow from another industry?
• Modify — What could we exaggerate or change?
• Put to another use — What else could this become?
• Eliminate — What can we remove?
• Reverse/Rearrange — What if we flipped the process?

CanvaExample: Existing idea: “A coffee brand launches a loyalty app.”

SCAMPER prompts:

• Combine: What if loyalty became a community?
• Eliminate: What if customers never needed points?
• Reverse: What if customers rewarded the brand?

5. Six Thinking Hats for strategic perspective shifts

Useful when teams get stuck because everyone is approaching the problem from the same viewpoint.

Participants deliberately switch modes:

• White Hat: Facts, data, research
• Red Hat: Feelings, intuition, emotional response
• Black Hat: Risks and weaknesses
• Yellow Hat: Benefits and opportunities
• Green Hat: New possibilities and creativity
• Blue Hat: Process and decisions

OpenStax University of South CarolinaThis is particularly valuable for brand strategy, campaign evaluation, and innovation workshops.

6. “Worst Possible Idea” exercise

Ask:

“What would be the worst possible campaign/product idea?” Examples:

• “How could we make customers hate this brand?”
• “How could we make this launch fail spectacularly?”

Then reverse the answers.

Bad idea:

• “Make the product impossible to understand.”

Reverse:

• “Create the clearest, simplest experience in the category.”

This lowers pressure and often reveals hidden assumptions.

7. Crazy 8s for rapid visual ideation

A fast sketching method:

• Fold paper into 8 sections.
• Generate 8 concepts in 8 minutes.
• No polishing.
• Quantity over quality.

Great for:

• Campaign concepts
• Packaging
• UX ideas
• Brand activations

The Meaning Movement## 8. Role storming (borrow another perspective)

Instead of asking:

“What would we do?” Ask:

• “What would Nike do?”
• “What would a startup with no budget do?”
• “What would our biggest critic suggest?”
• “What would a teenager invent?”

Changing identity breaks habitual thinking.

9. Trend and culture mining

Creative strategists should look beyond the category.

Explore:

• Emerging behaviors
• Internet communities
• Fashion/music/art movements
• Technology shifts
• Social tensions
• Competitor patterns

A useful prompt:

“What is changing in people’s lives that this brand can participate in?”

10. End with an idea selection framework

A brainstorm should not end with “great ideas everywhere.” It should create direction.

Score ideas against:

A strong 90-minute creative strategy session format

1. 10 min — Context

• Review brief, audience, constraints

2. 15 min — Inspiration

• Trends, examples, cultural observations

3. 25 min — Divergent ideation

• Brainwriting + mind mapping

4. 20 min — Concept expansion

• SCAMPER, role storming, “what if” prompts

5. 15 min — Evaluation

• Dot voting + strategic criteria

6. 5 min — Next steps

• Assign owners and experiments

The biggest shift for creative strategists is moving away from “come up with a great idea” toward designing a repeatable system that reliably produces many interesting possibilities.

A brainstorm should not end with “great ideas everywhere.” It should create direction.

Score ideas against:

A strong 90-minute creative strategy session format

1. 10 min — Context

• Review brief, audience, constraints

2. 15 min — Inspiration

• Trends, examples, cultural observations

3. 25 min — Divergent ideation

• Brainwriting + mind mapping

4. 20 min — Concept expansion

• SCAMPER, role storming, “what if” prompts

5. 15 min — Evaluation

• Dot voting + strategic criteria

6. 5 min — Next steps

• Assign owners and experiments

The biggest shift for creative strategists is moving away from “come up with a great idea” toward designing a repeatable system that reliably produces many interesting possibilities.

Running a killer brainstorming session as a creative strategist means moving past tired clichés and getting the room to actually unlock fresh, high-impact ideas. Here are the best methods broken down for maximum clarity and action:

• Crazy Eights : Fast-paced sketching or rapid-fire writing where participants fold a paper into eight rectangles and must fill each with a distinct idea or wireframe in just 8 minutes. It forces volume over perfection.
• SCAMPER : A prompt-driven framework (Substitute, Combine, Adapt, Modify, Put to another use, Eliminate, Reverse ) that takes an existing concept, product, or campaign and systematically twists it into something new.
• Six Thinking Hats : Edward de Bono’s technique where the entire team puts on the same "hat" (representing different perspectives like emotional, critical, creative, or factual) at the same time to look at a strategic problem from all angles without arguing.
• Worst Possible Idea : A reverse-psychology warm-up where the goal is to pitch the absolute worst, most illegal, or dumbest idea possible. It instantly shatters the pressure of the blank page and gets people laughing and talking.
• Brainwriting (6-3-5) : Six people write 3 ideas each on a sheet in 5 minutes, then pass the sheet to the next person who builds on them. It eliminates the loud-voice bias of traditional live meetings and gives introverts an equal playing field.
• Storyboarding / Journey Mapping : Visualizing a narrative or user experience step-by-step on a wall. Great for mapping out campaign touchpoints, emotional highs/lows, or product onboarding flows.

Would you like me to:

• Outline a step-by-step agenda for a 60-minute workshop?
• Provide digital collaboration tools best suited for these methods?

For a creative strategist, the best ideation sessions are rarely “just brainstorms.” They are designed experiences that move a team through distinct phases: understanding the challenge, generating possibilities, expanding perspectives, and then selecting ideas worth developing. Structured methods tend to outperform open-ended “throw ideas around” meetings because they reduce groupthink and premature judgment.

Here are some of the most effective methods:

1. Start with a strong creative brief and a provocative question

Before generating ideas, define the challenge.

Weak prompt:

“How can we market this product?”

Stronger prompts:

“How might we make people feel proud to choose this product?”

“How would we launch this if advertising didn’t exist?”

“How could we make this category feel completely different?”

Good ideation starts with the right question; better questions often produce better ideas than simply asking teams to “be creative.”

---

2. Use divergent → convergent thinking cycles

A common mistake is evaluating ideas while they are still being created.

A stronger flow:

Phase 1: Diverge

• Generate many possibilities
• Suspend criticism
• Explore unusual directions

Phase 2: Converge

• Cluster ideas
• Identify patterns
• Score opportunities
• Choose concepts to develop

This keeps creativity from being shut down too early.

---

High-impact ideation techniques

3. Brainwriting (better than traditional brainstorming for many teams)

Instead of everyone shouting ideas, participants write ideas silently first, then build on each other’s concepts.

Useful when:

• Senior people dominate conversations
• Teams are remote
• You need more diverse input

A popular variation is the 6-3-5 method:

• 6 people
• 3 ideas each
• 5 minutes per round

It creates a large volume of ideas while reducing social pressure.

---

4. SCAMPER

Great for improving existing products, campaigns, or strategies.

Ask:

• S — Substitute: What could we replace?
• C — Combine: What could we merge?
• A — Adapt: What can we borrow from another industry?
• M — Modify: What could we exaggerate or transform?
• P — Put to another use: How else could this work?
• E — Eliminate: What could we remove?
• R — Reverse: What if we flipped the process?

Example: A coffee brand might ask:

• What if coffee subscriptions worked like Netflix?
• What if we removed stores entirely?
• What if customers designed their own blends?

---

5. Analogical thinking (“borrow brilliance”)

Creative strategists often find breakthroughs by looking sideways.

Prompts:

• “How would a luxury hotel solve this?”
• “How would a gaming company approach this?”
• “What would nature teach us?”
• “How would a startup with no budget solve this?”

Examples:

• Airline loyalty programs borrowing from gaming mechanics
• Retail experiences borrowing from entertainment
• Brand communities borrowing from fan cultures

---

6. Reverse brainstorming

Instead of asking:

“How do we improve customer engagement?”

Ask:

“How could we make customers hate this brand?”

The team generates negative scenarios:

• Make everything complicated
• Ignore customers
• Remove personalization

Then reverse those answers into opportunities.

Useful for:

• Finding blind spots
• Challenging assumptions
• Improving customer experiences

---

7. Mind mapping

Start with a central idea and branch outward.

Example:

Center: “Future of fitness”

Branches:

• Technology
• Community
• Personalization
• Entertainment
• Wellness
• Identity

Then branch again:

• Technology → AI coaches → wearable feedback → adaptive training

Mind maps help reveal connections that linear lists miss.

---

8. Role storming

Have participants think from another perspective.

Examples:

• “How would a teenager solve this?”
• “How would a competitor attack this?”
• “How would a comedian approach this?”
• “How would a five-star hospitality brand approach this?”

This is especially useful when teams are trapped in industry assumptions.

---

9. Crazy 8s

A fast visual ideation exercise:

• Fold paper into eight sections
• Spend one minute per idea
• Sketch eight possible solutions

Best for:

• Campaign concepts
• Product ideas
• Visual directions
• Experience design

The time constraint forces people past their first obvious answers.

---

10. Trend and cultural tension mapping

For strategy work, ideas often come from identifying tensions.

Framework:

Cultural shift + Human desire + Brand role

Creative opportunity

Example:

Cultural shift: “People distrust polished perfection”

Human desire: “Authenticity and belonging”

Brand role: “Help people celebrate imperfection”

Opportunity: A campaign built around real stories rather than idealized imagery.

---

A strong 90-minute creative strategy session format

0–10 min: Context

• Define objective
• Share insights
• Establish constraints

10–20 min: Reframe

Use:

• “How might we…”
• “What if…”
• “Imagine if…”

20–50 min: Generate

Run:

• Brainwriting
• Crazy 8s
• SCAMPER
• Analogies

50–70 min: Expand

Combine ideas:

• “What happens if we merge these two?”
• “What’s the bigger version?”
• “What’s the unexpected version?”

70–90 min: Select

Score ideas on:

• Strategic fit
• Originality
• Audience relevance
• Feasibility
• Potential impact

---

Facilitation principles that make sessions work

• Separate creation from criticism.
• Capture every idea visibly.
• Use constraints to increase creativity.
• Invite different disciplines into the room.
• End with decisions, not just ideas.

Traditional brainstorming rules—such as deferring judgment, encouraging unusual ideas, generating volume, and building on others’ ideas—remain useful because they protect the creative phase from being dominated by evaluation.

For a creative strategist specifically, the strongest combination is usually: insight mining → provocative questions → brainwriting → SCAMPER/analogy exercises → concept clustering → strategic selection.

Effective brainstorming and ideation for a creative strategist balances structured frameworks with wild, divergent thinking. The goal is to move beyond the obvious first ideas and uncover sharp strategic insights that spark culturally resonant campaigns.

Top Methods for Creative Ideation

1. SCAMPER : A prompt-based technique where you take an existing product, campaign, or idea and S ubstitute, C ombine, A dapt, M odify, P ut to another use, E liminate, or R everse it. It forces lateral thinking from a solid baseline.
2. Crazy Eights : A fast-paced sketching or rapid-writing exercise where participants fold a paper into eight rectangles and have just eight minutes to generate eight distinct ideas (one minute per idea). It stops overthinking and kills the inner perfectionist.
3. How Might We (HMW) : Framing core problems or consumer tensions into "HMW" statements (e.g., "HMW make the checkout process feel like a reward?"). It frames challenges as actionable, optimistic springboards for ideation.
4. Opposite Thinking (Inversion) : Asking the inverse of your goal. If the brief is "How do we get Gen Z to trust our brand?", ask "How could we make Gen Z completely despise and distrust our brand in 30 seconds?" Reviewing the disaster list often reveals hidden truths and assumptions to flip.
5. Analogical Thinking : Borrowing models from completely unrelated industries (e.g., "How would Airbnb handle luxury auto insurance?"). It forces the brain to bridge gaps and find unexpected execution styles.
6. The 6-3-5 Brainwriting Method : Six people write down three ideas each on a sheet of paper in five minutes, then pass the sheet to the next person, who builds on or modifies those ideas. It prevents loud voices from dominating the room.

Would you like me to dive deeper into how to structure a workshop agenda for one of these methods, or do you have a specific creative brief in mind that we can brainstorm for?

For a creative strategist, the best ideation sessions aren't simply “let's brainstorm.” Your job is to create the conditions for divergent thinking first, then disciplined convergence. IDEO describes ideation similarly: generate broadly, then narrow toward promising concepts rather than trying to find the answer immediately.

Here are the methods I’d put in a creative strategist's toolkit:

1. Start with a sharp “How Might We?” question

Instead of:

“How can we market this product?”

Try:

“How might we make people want to talk about this product?”

Or:

“How might we make this category feel culturally relevant to Gen Z?”

A good prompt creates a creative playing field without prescribing the answer.

2. Brainwriting before group brainstorming

Have everyone silently generate 5–10 ideas before anyone speaks.

This is especially useful with:

• senior executives in the room
• introverts
• highly opinionated teams
• groups where one person tends to dominate

It also reduces the tendency for everyone's thinking to converge around the first idea mentioned.

3. “Yes, and…” building

Take an existing idea and force the next person to add to it rather than critique it.

Idea: “What if the brand created a pop-up restaurant?”

Build: “Yes, and every dish represents a customer pain point.”

Build: “Yes, and people have to solve the pain point to order.”

This embodies one of IDEO's core brainstorming principles: build on others' ideas rather than judging them prematurely.

4. SCAMPER

Excellent when you need to push an existing concept somewhere unexpected:

• Substitute
• Combine
• Adapt
• Modify
• Put to another use
• Eliminate
• Reverse

It's particularly useful when the team keeps producing variations of the same safe idea. SCAMPER is among the structured creativity techniques studied in creativity research.

5. Constraint brainstorming

Paradoxically, constraints can make brainstorming more creative.

Instead of:

“Give me campaign ideas.”

Try:

• “What if we had zero media budget?”
• “What if the campaign had to work without showing the product?”
• “What if we could only use one sentence?”
• “What if this had to become a cultural ritual?”
• “What if a competitor launched it?”
• “What would we do if we had 10× the budget?”

The constraint changes the mental model.

6. Reverse brainstorming

Ask the opposite question.

Instead of:

“How do we make customers love this brand?”

Ask:

“How could we make customers absolutely hate this brand?”

Generate the worst possible ideas, then reverse them.

This is particularly powerful when a team is stuck in conventional thinking.

7. Six Thinking Hats

Use different mental modes deliberately rather than letting everyone debate simultaneously:

• White: What do we know?
• Red: What do we feel?
• Black: What could go wrong?
• Yellow: What's exciting about this?
• Green: What else could we invent?
• Blue: What's the strategic conclusion?

The technique is designed to separate modes of thinking, and research has found that the green/creative framing combined with speed can increase the number and flexibility of unique ideas.

8. Random stimulus / forced connections

Introduce something unrelated—a movie, luxury hotel, TikTok trend, sports team, children's game, fashion brand, historical event—and ask:

“What could we steal from this?”

For example:

Brand challenge: Increase loyalty.

Stimulus: Airline frequent-flyer programs.

Connection: Maybe loyalty shouldn't be about discounts; perhaps customers should accumulate status, access, or experiences.

This works because you're forcing the brain to make connections it wouldn't ordinarily make.

9. “What would [X] do?”

Change the strategic lens:

• What would Apple do?
• What would Nike do?
• What would a luxury brand do?
• What would a comedian do?
• What would a conspiracy theorist do?
• What would a 10-year-old do?
• What would a startup with $500 do?
• What would our biggest competitor never do?

The goal isn't to imitate those entities. It's to escape your team's default assumptions.

10. Crazy 8s

Give everyone 8 minutes to produce 8 different ideas.

The time pressure matters: research on ideation has found that speed/time pressure can increase the number and flexibility of ideas under certain conditions.

The key rule is:

Don't spend 7 minutes making one idea good. Make eight imperfect ideas.

11. “Kill the obvious”

After the first round, explicitly identify the predictable ideas:

“What would every agency in the world pitch?”

Put those aside.

Then ask:

“Now that we've killed the obvious answer, what's underneath it?”

This is one of my favorite techniques for creative strategy, because the strategist's job isn't merely to produce ideas—it's to find the interesting territory behind the obvious solution.

12. Idea mashups

Take two unrelated ideas and combine them:

Subscription + dating app
→ A subscription service that learns your preferences through swiping.

Museum + TikTok
→ A museum experience built around endlessly remixable cultural moments.

Fitness app + fantasy football
→ Compete with friends based on real-world fitness achievements.

The point isn't necessarily to use the mashup. It's to create a new conceptual territory.

---

The most important technique: separate divergence from convergence

A common failure is asking:

“Is this a good idea?”

too early.

Instead, run the session in two distinct modes:

Diverge → Generate lots of possibilities
→ No criticism
→ Build on ideas
→ Encourage absurdity
→ Work quickly

Converge → Cluster ideas
→ Identify patterns
→ Evaluate against strategy
→ Combine promising concepts
→ Select 3–5 territories
→ Develop the strongest ones

IDEO explicitly emphasizes this movement from broad generation toward narrowing and experimentation.

A strong 60-minute creative-strategy session

0–5 min — Frame
Define the problem and the “How Might We?” question.

5–10 min — Inspiration
Show 3–5 provocative examples, insights, cultural observations, or consumer truths.

10–15 min — Brainwriting
Everyone independently generates ideas.

15–25 min — Crazy 8s / SCAMPER
Push beyond the first layer of thinking.

25–35 min — Build
Share ideas and use “Yes, and…” to develop them.

35–42 min — Wild-card round
Reverse brainstorming, random stimulus, or “What would X do?”

42–50 min — Cluster
Group ideas into themes or territories.

50–57 min — Evaluate
Score against criteria such as:

• strategic relevance
• distinctiveness
• cultural potential
• audience resonance
• feasibility
• ability to own the territory

57–60 min — Choose next steps
Select the strongest territories, not necessarily finished executions.

---

One principle I'd emphasize above everything else

Don't ask a room of people to “be creative.” Give them a sequence of different cognitive jobs.

For example:

Observe → Reframe → Generate → Exaggerate → Combine → Challenge → Select

That's what makes a strategist valuable as the facilitator. You're not just harvesting whatever ideas happen to emerge; you're engineering the thinking process that produces better ideas.

And keep the initial environment deliberately judgment-free. IDEO's widely used brainstorming rules emphasize deferring judgment, encouraging wild ideas, building on others, staying focused, being visual, and prioritizing quantity.

IDEO's brainstorming resources are a particularly good reference if you want to build a repeatable facilitation practice.

As a creative strategist, running a high-impact brainstorming and ideation session requires moving past clichés and unstructured chatter. The best methods provide frameworks to unlock diverse perspectives, handle different personality types in the room, and translate abstract concepts into actionable strategic directions.

• Mind Mapping (Starbursting): Start with a central core challenge or a single H₂O-pure strategic objective, then branch outward into categories like Who, What, Where, When, Why, and How. It helps visualize non-linear connections.
• SCAMPER: A prompt-driven checklist technique where you take an existing idea or competitor strategy and systematically Substitute, Combine, Adapt, Modify, Put to another use, Eliminate, or Reverse it.
• Crazy Eights: A fast-paced sketch exercise where participants fold a piece of paper into eight panels and have 8 minutes to sketch or write 8 distinct ideas (1 minute per panel). It forces volume over perfection.
• Worst Possible Idea (Reverse Brainstorming): Ask the team to intentionally pitch the absolute worst, most disastrous, or most unfeasible ideas imaginable. It breaks the ice, eliminates the fear of judgment, and often flips effortlessly into brilliant counter-ideas.
• Six Thinking Hats: Edward de Bono’s framework where the entire room adopts a specific "hat" simultaneously (White for data/facts, Red for gut feelings, Black for critical risks, Yellow for optimistic benefits, Green for creative leaps, Blue for process management).
• Analogous Inspiration: Look outside your direct industry or category. Ask how a completely unrelated field—like hospitality, aerospace, or independent gaming—solves a similar behavioral challenge.

Would you like me to dive deeper into how to structure an agenda for a 90-minute session, or share tips on managing difficult or dominant personalities in the room?

For a creative strategist, the best ideation sessions aren't simply “get everyone in a room and brainstorm.” The strategist's real job is to create the conditions for better thinking: frame the problem, generate divergent possibilities, then deliberately converge on ideas that are strategically relevant.

A strong approach combines several methods rather than relying on one.

1. Start with a sharp creative challenge

Before generating ideas, turn the business problem into a provocative question.

Instead of:

“How do we increase awareness?”

Try:

“How might we make people want to talk about this brand?”

Or:

“What would make this product impossible to ignore?”

A good prompt gives people a direction without prescribing the answer. IDEO similarly recommends grounding brainstorming in a focused challenge and insight.

2. Separate divergence from convergence

This is probably the most important principle.

Diverge → explore → converge → develop.

Don't evaluate ideas while people are still generating them. First create a large pool; then switch into critical thinking to select, combine and develop the strongest territories. Both divergent and convergent thinking are essential to moving from possibilities to viable directions.

A useful session structure is:

10 min: Context + insight
5 min: Creative warm-up
15 min: Individual ideation
15 min: Group building/mash-ups
10 min: Cluster into territories
15 min: Evaluate and prioritize
10 min: Develop the 2–3 strongest ideas

3. Use brainwriting before group brainstorming

Rather than immediately asking, “Who has an idea?”, give everyone 5–10 minutes to generate ideas individually.

This prevents the loudest or most senior person from setting the direction too early and gives quieter participants equal creative space.

Then put everyone's ideas on the wall and build from them.

4. Use SCAMPER when people get stuck

SCAMPER is excellent for creative strategists because it gives you structured provocations rather than waiting for inspiration.

Take an existing idea and ask:

• Substitute — What could we replace?
• Combine — What could we merge?
• Adapt — What could we borrow from elsewhere?
• Modify — What could we exaggerate, shrink or change?
• Put to another use — What else could this become?
• Eliminate — What could we remove?
• Rearrange — What could we reverse or reorder?

It's particularly useful when the team is producing variations on the same obvious concept.

5. Use “What if…?” provocations

This is one of my favorites for strategy work.

Take the conventional assumption and deliberately break it:

• What if we couldn't use advertising?
• What if the campaign had to spread without paid media?
• What if the product were a cultural movement?
• What if we had $0 budget?
• What if we had to explain it in three seconds?
• What if our biggest competitor didn't exist?
• What if we had to make the audience do something rather than watch something?

The point isn't necessarily to use the resulting idea. It's to escape the mental model everyone walked into the room with.

6. Try analogy and cross-industry inspiration

Ask:

“Who solves a similar problem brilliantly, even though they're in a completely different category?”

For example:

Nike × gaming
A bank × hospitality
A streaming service × fandom
A B2B SaaS brand × luxury fashion

Then ask:

“What principle could we steal—not literally copy—from that world?”

This is particularly powerful for strategists because it converts cultural observation into creative territory.

7. Use constraint-based ideation

Counterintuitively, constraints often make brainstorming better.

Instead of:

“Come up with campaign ideas.”

Try:

“Come up with a campaign that requires no traditional advertising.”

Or:

“Generate 20 ideas that could happen entirely in the physical world.”

Or:

“What could we do if the idea had to be understood without words?”

Constraints force the brain to search somewhere other than its default answers.

8. Use mash-ups

Take two unrelated things and force them together.

Brand truth + cultural behavior
Product feature + unexpected format
Audience tension + technology
Brand asset + entertainment property

For example:

“What happens when we combine [brand behavior] with [unexpected cultural behavior]?”

The resulting ideas don't all need to be good. You're looking for combinations that create unexpected strategic territory.

9. Make the session visual

Don't let brainstorming become a 60-minute conversation.

Put ideas on sticky notes, sketch them, create crude storyboards, collect images, build moodboards, write headlines, map customer journeys.

IDEO explicitly recommends visualizing ideas and going for quantity; its guidance even suggests aiming for around 100 ideas in a 60-minute brainstorm.

For a creative strategist, a rough visual can communicate an idea far more effectively than a five-minute explanation.

10. Use “How Might We?” reframing

If the team keeps solving the wrong problem, stop brainstorming and reframe the question.

For example:

“How might we get Gen Z to notice us?”

could become:

“How might we give Gen Z something worth noticing?”

Or:

“How might we get people to use the product more?”

becomes:

“How might we make the product part of a behavior people already enjoy?”

The reframing itself can unlock more valuable ideas.

---

The method I'd recommend most

For a creative strategist, I'd combine the techniques into a 5-stage ideation system:

1. INSIGHT
Start with a genuine human/cultural/business tension.

↓

2. REFRAME
Turn it into a provocative “How might we…?” question.

↓

3. DIVERGE
Brainwriting → SCAMPER → provocations → analogies → mash-ups.

↓

4. CLUSTER
Group hundreds of individual ideas into 5–8 larger creative territories.

↓

5. CONVERGE
Evaluate territories against criteria such as:

• Strategic relevance
• Distinctiveness
• Cultural resonance
• Brand fit
• Emotional power
• Feasibility
• Potential to scale

This is much more effective than simply voting on individual ideas. You're looking for the idea behind the ideas.

One rule I'd emphasize above everything else

Don't ask “Is this a good idea?” too early.

Ask:

“What could this become?”

IDEO's classic brainstorming principles similarly emphasize deferring judgment, encouraging wild ideas, building on others' ideas, staying focused, being visual, and prioritizing quantity.

The creative strategist's advantage is knowing that the first idea is rarely the destination. Your job is to create enough distance from the obvious answer that the interesting answer has a chance to emerge.

Effective brainstorming and ideation for a creative strategist require a blend of divergent thinking (generating lots of ideas) and convergent thinking (filtering and refining for strategy).

Here are the best methods to structure high-impact sessions:

• SCAMPER : A prompt-based technique where you take an existing idea, product, or campaign and S ubstitute, C ombine, A dapt, M odify, P ut to another use, E liminate, or R everse it to spark fresh angles.
• Crazy Eights : A fast-paced sketching or rapid-writing exercise where participants fold a paper into eight rectangles and have just 8 minutes (1 minute per box) to jot down or sketch eight distinct ideas. It forces volume over perfection.
• Brainwriting (6-3-5 Method) : Six people write down three ideas each on a sheet of paper in 5 minutes, then pass the sheet to the next person, who builds on those ideas. This eliminates the loudest-voice-in-the-room bias.
• The Walt Disney Method : A role-playing strategy where the team looks at a challenge through three distinct lenses sequentially: The Dreamer (unfiltered optimism and wild ideas), The Realist (how to make it practical), and The Critic (identifying flaws and risks).
• Worst Possible Idea (Reverse Brainstorming) : Ask the team to intentionally generate the absolute worst, most impractical, or brand-destroying ideas possible. It breaks the ice, relieves performance anxiety, and often flips directly into brilliant counter-insights.
• Starbursting : Instead of generating solutions, the team focuses entirely on generating questions. Draw a six-pointed star with the core idea in the center and ask Who, What, Where, When, Why , and How at each point to stress-test the strategic foundation.

Would you like me to tailor a step-by-step workshop agenda using one of these methods, or do you need help with how to pitch these frameworks to skeptical stakeholders?